ESSave

Hay Beach Hideaway

Town of Shelter Island, New York, United States

  • 3 bedrooms
  • 2 baths
  • Sleeps 5
  • Private pool
  • Wi-Fi
  • Air conditioning
  • Parking
Show all 41 photos

The home accommodates up to five guests in three bedrooms with two full bathrooms. The living room has a large sectional, a flat-screen TV, windows and…

Read more

Listing description

The home accommodates up to five guests in three bedrooms with two full bathrooms. The living room has a large sectional, a flat-screen TV, windows and sliding doors. A separate dining room seats six and opens onto a deck. The kitchen has a pass-through to the dining room, wood cabinetry and stainless-steel appliances, including a stove, oven, refrigerator and dishwasher. A Keurig coffee maker, toaster, cookware and tableware are provided.

All three bedrooms are on the main floor of the main house and have air conditioning and closets. The primary bedroom has a king bed and a full ensuite bathroom with a marble shower/tub combination, a deep jetted tub and multiple showerheads. Bedroom 2 has a TV. Both full bathrooms have shower/tub combinations.

Outdoor spaces include over 4,500 square feet of decks and patios, a 2,500-square-foot marble pool patio, outdoor dining areas, a gas grill and lounge seating. The private outdoor saltwater pool measures 21 by 42 feet and is heated and fenced. The backyard is also fenced. Six lounge chairs, four beach chairs and one adult bicycle are provided.

The home has central air conditioning, heating, Wi-Fi, cable and smart TV, a Bluetooth speaker system, a washer and dryer, bed linens, bath towels and pool/beach towels. Driveway parking accommodates four cars. Nearby beaches include Menhaden Lane Beach, Hay Beach and Ram's Head; Shelter Island restaurants and shops are close by. The homeowner handles on-the-ground operations and guest communication after booking confirmation.

Good to know. A sandy beach is a three-minute walk away. The property is not suitable for persons with disabilities or children. The primary renter must be at least 30 years old. A maximum of four unrelated guests is allowed.Things to know ›

Before you book

Check-in
Not provided by the host
Checkout
Not provided by the host
Pets
Welcome, per the host
House rules
Reservations require approval before confirmation. Smoking is not allowed. 00 per person per night may apply. Events require express approval and may incur a $2,000 event fee. All house rules ›
Nearby
  • Groceries Schmidts Market Shelter Island · 3.7 km straight-line
Straight-line distances from the location of Hay Beach Hideaway. No pedestrian route was computed. Places come from a licensed open dataset; sources are listed around the home. Around the home ›
Sleeps
Sleeps 5
Pool
Private
Good to know
A sandy beach is a three-minute walk away. The property is not suitable for persons with disabilities or children. The primary renter must be at least 30 years old. A maximum of four unrelated guests is allowed.
How to book
Check dates & priceYou won’t be charged here; the host confirms and takes payment.
Cancellation and payment terms
See the host’s own listing text in the house rules and FAQ, and confirm cancellation and payment terms with the host before booking. Ask on the host’s site ›
  • Online date and price check verified Oct 29, 2026, valid until Nov 12, 2026.
  • Listing updated Oct 29, 2026. Not an independent verification.
Compare with another property

Method: start with this page's listed facts, open another property's source page, then fill in the same fields. Missing information means ask the host. These facts are not independently verified; this worksheet does not rank properties.

Source: Hay Beach Hideaway. Page last updated (UTC): . A page update is not a verification date. Confirm dates and terms with each host and note when they replied.

Compare facts and host-confirmed terms
ItemHay Beach HideawayAnother property
Source pageHay Beach Hideaway
SleepsSleeps 5
PoolPrivate
PetsYes
Good to knowA sandy beach is a three-minute walk away. The property is not suitable for persons with disabilities or children. The primary renter must be at least 30 years old. A maximum of four unrelated guests is allowed.
How to bookCheck dates & price
Dates and party size
Total price and currency
Deposit and payment terms
Cancellation terms
Host confirmation date

Chucho does not save or send these notes. Copy them before leaving the page. A total price should include mandatory fees, taxes and currency for the same dates and party size.

Ask about the houseAnswers from what the host has published here.

Hay Beach Hideaway offers accommodation in Town of Shelter Island, New York, United States. Sleeps 5 · 3 bedrooms · 2 baths · Private pool · Kitchen · Wi-Fi · Air conditioning · Parking · Pets allowed · Washing machine. Contact the host directly at staymarquis.com. The host confirms dates and prices.

Confirm dates, total price, deposit and cancellation terms with the host. Wi-Fi and arrival instructions are shared with booked guests only. After you book ›

Check dates & price

Check dates and price before continuing with the host. A check does not reserve your stay. No contact or card details needed.

Capacity counts adults and children. The check prices everyone staying; the host confirms child rates.

Pets welcome, per the host.

Nothing is reserved. You won’t be charged here; the host confirms and takes payment.

Go to the host’s website

Cobbetts Contemporary

Town of Shelter Island, United States

3 bedrooms · 6 beds · 2.5 baths · sleeps 8 · private pool

A contemporary holiday home in Shelter Island with three bedrooms, an additional sleeping loft and a private heated outdoor pool.

Visit host websitestaymarquis.com

Shelter Island Escape

Town of Shelter Island, United States

7 bedrooms · 9 beds · 5.5 baths · sleeps 14 · private pool

A gated, seven-bedroom home with a separate guest house and a private heated outdoor pool in Shelter Island Heights.

Visit host websitestaymarquis.com

Shelter Island Serene

Town of Shelter Island, United States

4 bedrooms · 5 beds · 3 baths · sleeps 6

A renovated, nautically themed vacation house in a Shelter Island waterfront community, with Menantic Creek access and a pool house.

Visit host websitestaymarquis.com

Great Circle Serenity

Town of Shelter Island, United States

5 bedrooms · 7 beds · 4 baths · sleeps 10 · private pool

Great Circle Serenity is a vacation home in Shelter Island with five bedrooms, additional guest-house sleeping space, a private pool and a private tennis court.

Visit host websitestaymarquis.com

Ram Island Beauty

Town of Shelter Island, United States

4 bedrooms · 4 beds · 4 baths · sleeps 8 · private pool

Renovated ranch house on Big Ram Island, Shelter Island, with partial Coecles Harbor views, a private heated pool and a detached sleeping cabana, accommodating up to eight guests.

Visit host websitestaymarquis.com

Shelter Island Preserve

Town of Shelter Island, United States

4 bedrooms · 5 beds · 3 baths · sleeps 10 · private pool

A four-bedroom holiday home on over an acre in Shelter Island, minutes from the ferry, with an additional sleeping space and a private heated pool.

Visit host websitestaymarquis.com

Amagansett Hideaway

Amagansett, United States

5 bedrooms · 5 beds · 4.5 baths · sleeps 10 · private pool

A recently renovated cottage on a private block in Amagansett, near town and beaches, accommodating up to 10 guests.

Visit host websitestaymarquis.com

Bay Shore Modern

Hampton Bays, United States

4 bedrooms · 4 beds · 3.5 baths · sleeps 8 · private pool

Modern four-bedroom vacation home in Hampton Bays for up to eight guests, with a private heated outdoor pool.

Visit host websitestaymarquis.com

Hay Beach Hideaway

Ask about the house

Chucho Hi! Ask me anything about Hay Beach Hideaway. I answer only from what the host has published here, and the host confirms dates and prices.